Google hacked by climategate deniers?
This is very strange. I cannot believe that “climate gatlinburg” is a more common search than “climate gate”. But I also don’t believe that Google is deliberately gaming their search tool to hide the scandal. So what’s up here? Is it possible that the algorithm1 for how they choose what goes in that menu can be gamed from the outside?
Bing gets it at “cli”. Yahoo at “climat”. I’m nearly certain that Google was getting it within the first couple of letters when I wrote The (para)psychology of climate change research. I remember wondering whether it should be “climategate” or climate-something else, and going to Google to see what people were using most.
It never occurred to me I might need a screenshot of the hints menu, so I can’t be absolutely certain. But the fact that Bing and Yahoo both show climategate in their hints when Google doesn’t indicates something odd is happening.
The disappearing hints appeared to start in Google Canada before moving to the main Google.com search page. When Kate from Canada first noted the disappearance, people were still finding Climategate and the other missing hints in the google.com hints menu. This sounds to me like a database issue.
Another clue is that “climate gates” is still appearing. Whatever’s causing the various forms of the term “climategate” to disappear didn’t catch that plural. It could be a combination of Bill Gates (or his Gates Foundation) and climate. It might also be a search on the “Climate Auto Gates” company. Whatever it is, the actual search pulls up “climate gate” before anything about Bill, though not before the auto company (because the auto company has both words in the title of its home page).
I’ve sent an e-mail to Google asking if they know what’s up.
- November 30, 2009: Google responds to Climategate-gate
-
I received a response from Jake Hubert of Google’s Public Affairs department a little after noon today. +1 for responding, -100 for not actually answering the question.
I asked:
Is the hints algorithm being hacked in some way? I'm nearly certain that climategate was showing Thursday morning.
Jake responded:
I can verify that Google has not removed the query [climategate] or variations of the query from Google Suggest. In fact, [climategate] is already appearing as a suggestion (see attached screen shot).
Google Suggest uses a variety of algorithms in order to come up with relevant suggestions while the user is typing. We do remove certain clearly pornographic or hateful or malicious slur terms from Suggest.
To learn more about Google Suggest, read the following blog post: http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/08/at-loss-for-words.html
I suspect it’s a form response answering the question everyone else was asking, rather than the one I asked. I never believed that Google itself removed the variations on climategate, which is why I didn’t ask that question. We know from experience that other aspects of Google can be hacked to provide desired responses, so I thought it might be happening here. It could also be a rogue employee; or it could be that everyone who noticed it is misremembering the term showing up earlier; I doubt the latter.
For what it’s worth, I saw climategate return as the top suggestion (after typing “clim”, which wasn’t quite as good as Bing’s “cli”) by quarter to five on Saturday. I was waiting to see if Google was going to respond before posting.
It’s too bad there isn’t a wayback machine for trending suggestions on Google and other search engines. That would be interesting to browse back through.
Cue Al Gore jokes here.
↑
- Climate Emails: Don’t Google It: Kate McMillan at small dead animals
- “Typically, when you begin to type in search terms, a drop down window will appear to provide helpful suggestions, based on the search terms Google users are typing in most often. A couple of days ago, typing the word ‘climate’ into the window resulted in ‘climate hack’ and ‘climate emails’ popping up near the top of the handy helper suggestion list. Today, Google’s handy helper seems to have had a change of heart.” (Hat tip to krakatoa at Ace of Spades HQ)
More global warming
- Climate priests cry wolf one more time?
- In science, if your theory’s predictions don’t happen, you need a new theory. In religion, if your beliefs predict something that doesn’t happen, you just keep moving that prediction further into the future.
- Can Californians drink a train?
- The meme goes that even if we’re wrong about global warming, the money spent will still make the world a better place. That is only true if you can drink a high-speed train.
- Cargo cult climate science
- When your real-world evidence contradicts your theory, that isn’t a boon for deniers; that’s a boon for you, because, if you are a scientist, that is how your scientific knowledge advances. Real scientists are embarrassed when they ignore real-world evidence in favor of a mere theory.
- Republican President must keep Roosevelt’s word
- Even if a future conservative president doesn’t believe Americans of Japanese descent are disloyal, says Irwin Stelzer, he should think twice before rescinding President Roosevelt’s Executive Orders. The President’s honor—and the nation’s—is more important than politics.
- Another victim of climate change: science reporting
- The needs of religious reporting are completely different from the needs of science reporting. Treating climate change as a religion is killing science reporting. If we’re not careful, it will kill science as well.
- 14 more pages with the topic global warming, and other related pages
More Google
- What app keeps stealing focus?
- I’ve been having a problem on Mac OS X with something stealing focus. Here’s how to at least find out what that something is.
- Google: This is a closed out of date discussion
- Google’s Blogger forms are a bit on the wonky side when they close a topic.
- Climategate crashes Google?
- Google is claiming that, in order to provide the most relevant, objective results in Google News, they need to toss ones that people want to read and comment on. What?
- Google responds to Climategate-gate
- I’m guessing Google got a lot of questions about this; their response didn’t answer my question.
- Google Maps location-sensitive ads?
- It looks like Google Maps is providing location-sensitive ads.
- One more page with the topic Google, and other related pages
Remember: Trump reassures crowd after assassination attempt fails. (read more…)