Sometimes you wonder, other times you expunge the vote
A friend of mine has a saying: “Sometimes you wonder; and other times you know.” In the latest California budget, state assemblyman Chuck DeVore successfully convinced the senate to pass a bill—ABX4 23—to open up the possibility of off-shore oil leases to help balance the California budget—without building more oil rigs. On July 24, the assembly killed it on a nearly straight party-line vote.
But you won’t find that vote in the California assembly’s record. Immediately after the vote, assembly majority leader Alberto Torrico (D-Fremont) made a motion to expunge the vote. I knew nothing about it until I read part two of Gabriel Malor’s DeVore interview on the Ace of Spades, where DeVore mentioned it in passing:
The only piece of recurring, non-tax revenue that was in the budget was something I authored. It was a bill that would have opened up the first off-shore oil leases in California in 40 years. It passed the state Senate and then the Sierra Club and other radical environmental groups did a full-court press to kill it. They were able to succeed in the Assembly where it died, I think, on a 43-28 vote. So 43 no, 28 yes. There were a couple Democrats voting for it. And then, of course, the vote was expunged, which got me on Stuart Marty’s show and talking about that.
Apparently the California assembly expunging votes is not unheard of, but it usually happens late nights when no one’s watching, not in the middle of the afternoon. Agree or disagree with the bill, expunging the votes is bullshit. Sometimes I wonder how screwed up California politics is; other times, I know. This is screwed.
You can see the votes at sfgate.com at the bottom of Erase the cowardice or Glenn Beck’s Vote Expunged.
- DeVore on the expunged offshore oil drilling vote in California: Stuart Varney
- “George Orwell would be proud of the California state assembly… Expunging votes unfortunately is not all too infrequent in the state assembly. We probably do it about two or three times a year on controversial measures.”
- Erase the cowardice
- “Don’t bother looking for the California Assembly's roll-call record of one of the most contentious issues of the budget revisions: the plan to open new offshore oil drilling off the Santa Barbara coast for the first time in 40 years. It’s not there.”
- Glenn Beck: Vote ‘Expunged’: Glenn Beck
- “You might not believe this story. It’s even too crazy for California.” Includes a copy of Chuck DeVore’s list of who voted what.
- Off Shore Oil Drilling Votes Expunged: Patrick McGreevy
- “This isn’t 1955 where you can contain this kind of information and a collegial press will play along,” DeVore said. But the article I’m pulling this from? Doesn’t list the votes.
- Offshore oil drilling solves problems: Debra J. Saunders
- “When the tax revenues were flowing, it was easy to oppose offshore oil drilling—because, as Oregon Gov. Ted Kulongoski put it at a federal hearing on offshore drilling, supporting drillings ‘sends the wrong message.’ But saying no to offshore oil drilling while driving is a message in itself. And Californians need to have a realistic policy—to go along with the real needs of Californians.”
- On the Record With Chuck Devore, Part II: Gabriel Malor at Ace of Spades HQ
- “The only piece of recurring, non-tax revenue that was in the budget was something I authored. It was a bill that would have opened up the first off-shore oil leases in California in 40 years. It passed the state Senate and then the Sierra Club and other radical environmental groups did a full-court press to kill it. They were able to succeed in the Assembly where it died, I think, on a 43-28 vote. So 43 no, 28 yes. There were a couple Democrats voting for it. And then, of course, the vote was expunged, which got me on Stuart Marty’s show and talking about that.”
More California
- California never had a free market power failure
- California’s experiment in free market power generation has become mythological in how it is remembered. The left is desperate to tar it as a free market failure. But California’s experiment wasn’t free market. It was a massive government-managed exchange practically designed to cause high prices.
- Can Californians drink a train?
- The meme goes that even if we’re wrong about global warming, the money spent will still make the world a better place. That is only true if you can drink a high-speed train.
- California threatens Amazon, kills affiliate programs
- By this time, California had to know that its new law would not bring in new tax revenue. The tax headaches aren’t worth the trouble of maintaining affiliate programs. The only reason to pass the law was to kill affiliate programs at places like Amazon and Overstock. I don’t understand; what is it about affiliate programs that states don’t like?
- Tax event horizon
- How close are we to a tax event horizon, where so many people’s income depends on complicated tax laws that they can never be reformed?
- California eminent domain reform: 98 or 99?
- Thanks to Ilya Somin on the Volokh Conspiracy for explaining why proposition 98 is the one that needs supporting.
- 10 more pages with the topic California, and other related pages