My philosophy: stop, look, and listen
I was just thinking this morning that Alaska’s system for absentee ballot counting is kind of nice. They’ll have one counting of most of them just seven days after the election, and another counting of any stragglers a few days later.
In a close election that everyone thought was going to go another way, such as the Miller-Murkowski election this year, there’s a tendency for the kind of people politicians are to think, in the flush of the loss, hey, this was just chance. If I try again I might win!
But they can’t—it would really suck to switch parties and discover you actually won the primary. For one thing, your chances of winning the general would be even lower than just switching parties; you’d be a joke.
A week without any counting gives time for passions to cool in a way that a week with counts trickling in would not do. By the time August 31 rolls around, Murkowski will be running less on adrenaline and more on reason; she’ll be less likely to make a rash decision on August 31 or September 3 or 8 (depending on how the tally changes) than if she had to watch the tally continually over this week. She may still make a poor decision—politicians are like that—but it’ll be less likely.
A delay gives the losing candidate in a close election time to go through the stages of grief and come down from the ledge. In a hotly-contested election like this, it also gives voters a chance to relax and consider their real choices.
Now I see Doug Brady on Conservatives 4 Palin calling for Murkowski to concede before the absentee ballot results are in. I love C4P; they’ve done very good work and are one of the few links in my blogroll because of it. But that’s wrong. In a race this close and this dynamic, it is reasonably possible that Murkowski could win. She almost certainly won’t. But it is reasonably possible, and for that reason it is wrong to ask her to concede. Alaska’s system is that the votes aren’t in until up to September 8. That system should be changed or respected, and in my opinion should be respected.
So I’m going to counter their call to Lisa with a call to Joe: say that you think candidates should stay in the race until the votes are in. Not just that it’s their right, but that it’s their responsibility. Their responsibility not to act rashly; their responsibility to wait for the true facts.
Waiting and seeing—and calming down—is a good strategy that we employ too rarely today. I’d like to see it a lot more in congress.
- Lunchtime Silly: No, The GOP Isn't Advising Lisa Murkowski On How To Run As A Libertarian: Ace at Ace of Spades HQ
- “Look, Murkowski is in shock. She never saw this coming. She is in the denial state of grief, or bargaining, or whatever. Point is, right now she’s angry and thinking about all sorts of nutty crap and it’s the GOP’s job to talk her down from the ledge.”
- Stacy McCain: It's All Over for Lisa Murkowski: Doug Brady at Conservatives 4 Palin
- “It’s clearly time for Lisa Murkowski to do the right thing and concede the election.”
- Stop, Look and Listen: Elvis Presley at Spinout•
- “Elvis performs ‘Stop, Look And Listen’ from the motion picture ‘Spinout’”.
More deliberative
- My Pet Crisis
- Someone needs to send President Obama a copy of The Pet Goat. Panic is not the right response to a financial crisis.
- Super-president
- The best president we can have is not a cartoon character.
- Televised debates discourage intelligent discussion
- Debates are a spectacle designed to trivialize the issues facing the community. And they are counter-productive because they specifically select for candidates who bullshit their way through the decision-making process rather than act deliberately and responsibly.
- More people need to read legislation
- The Boston Globe complains that the vice president’s office reads legislation looking to see how it affects the executive branch. More people should read bills to see how it affects them. There ought to be a law giving us all time to do it!
More Election 2010
- Don’t mess with the deck chairs, fix the boat!
- Advice for the incoming House. Make them deny it! And don’t try to fool us by changing the deck chairs.
- End of media; to delete this media…
- There will be a crisis: but this time they got caught manufacturing their crisis. And it’s a crisis of a most despicable kind: falsely tying a candidate to child molestation.
- San Diego’s proposition D: tax first, reform afterward
- San Diego’s proposition D is an attempt to raise taxes and then reform—which is, of course, an attempt to raise taxes and not reform anything at all.
- Nick Popaditch debates Bob Filner in CA-51
- Popaditch comes off as far more responsive to the needs of the community in this debate.
- There will be lies
- The media takes a blunder by Coons on the first amendment—and outright changes what both candidates said to make it look like a blunder by O’Donnell.
- 10 more pages with the topic Election 2010, and other related pages
More Joe Miller
- End of media; to delete this media…
- There will be a crisis: but this time they got caught manufacturing their crisis. And it’s a crisis of a most despicable kind: falsely tying a candidate to child molestation.
- No room for reason in Alaska
- Jesus Christ, what the hell are the Republicans doing up in Alaska?
- Tea Party vs. the news
- What a difference between the traditional news media (Google News) and what people are actually talking about (Memeorandum)!
Disclaimer: I donated to Joe Miller and am thrilled to see the underdog do so well in this race.