Georgia drug war unfairly targets Indian immigrants
In northwest George, 75% of convenience stores are run by whites, but they’ve been facing increasing competition from immigrants. The solution they’ve found is the same solution the United States governments have used since the mid-1800s: target the immigrants for drug trafficking.
In this case, the “drug trafficking” involved nothing more than selling perfectly legal items such as cold medicines, matches, and anti-freeze. Informants would, while purchasing the items, say things such as “I need this to finish a cook”.
Federal prosecutors are arguing that having heard this, the clerks and store owners were aware that these legal products were going to be used for an illegal purpose. This makes them guilty of “federal drug law violations punishable by up to 25 years in prison.”
The problem with this justification is that, not only do the accused sometimes not understand English very well, there’s no reason to expect that they understand drug slang either. Even the judges trying the cases had to have the slang explained to them:
Even the judges in the cases are having to have the meth-making slang explained to them, according to court documents, leading one defense attorney, McCracken Poston, to question why immigrants with limited English language abilities were supposed to know terminology sitting judges didn’t know. “They’re having to tell the court what that means,” Poston said. “But they’re assuming that the clerks know what it means. I think in most cases they had no idea,” he told the Associated Press last weekend.
“I have already watched people plead guilty to these charges, and they needed translators in court because they couldn’t understand what the judge was saying,” said Deepali Gokhale, campaign organizer for Raksha, a Georgia-based South Asian community association. “How are we to believe that they understood the coded slang of the undercover informant? Imagine you are in France, you barely know the language, or perhaps not at all, and someone comes up to you and starts talking in French drug slang. This is just bizarre,” she told DRCNet.
Further the interactions were not performed by law enforcement, but by informants--criminals hoping to get their time reduced, who were expected to “drop hints”. If their hints were vague enough so that the sale occurred, they were more likely to get time off than if they made it clear that they were about to do something illegal and the sale was refused.
You can’t get much more like entrapment than this without pointing a gun at someone. It’s crazy. But these kinds of laws against selling perfectly legal things just because you “should have known” are perfect vehicles for abuses of this sort. This is skinhead law enforcement; take advantage of an immigrant’s poor English skills and beat them down with complex, poorly-made laws.
- Federal Meth Precursor Sting Targeting South Asian Convenience Stores Draws Protests, ACLU Intervention
- “For several dozen hard-working South Asian immigrants and their families in northwest Georgia, the American dream has turned into a nightmare. Caught up in the federal government’s war on methamphetamine, they now face years in prison followed by deportation for selling legal products--from cold medicine to matches to antifreeze--to undercover informants.”
- Operation “Meth Merchant”
- “Prosecutors paid confidential informants--some former convicts, others offered the promise of lighter punishment for pending charges--to buy products in stores and drop hints that they were making drugs. The paid informants were criminals hoping to spend less time in jail.”
- Operation meth merchant unsealed
- “The defendants are charged with selling... Sudafed, Tylenol Cold and Sinus, and many other brand name and generic cold and sinus products.”
- Operation Meth Merchant
- “The New York Times report is delicately titled ‘Cultural Differences Complicate a Georgia Drug Sting Operation’ as if the story were more about silly cross-cultural foibles than insane law enforcement. Nowhere does the piece question whether anyone who was actually going to make meth would loudly proclaim the fact at the cash register.”
- ACLU Announces Defense of Indians Targeted in Meth Sting Operation
- “The investigation and subsequent charges relied heavily on the use of a confidential informant with a history of fraud convictions [who] has falsely identified at least five of the accused. About a dozen informants previously convicted of assorted crimes were promised reduced sentences for generating cases that could be ‘successfully’ prosecuted--arguably leading them to pursue a vulnerable, largely non-English speaking immigrant population.”
- Operation Meth Merchant nets jail full of Georgia convenience store clerks
- “They’re not cops, but now they’re expected to be, and that is what is truly egregious, even if it were white guys from Boston with Harvard degrees who understood exactly what was expected. What is expected is simply not reasonable...”
- Stop operation meth merchant
- “Take Action to Stop the Racially Targeted Prosecutions of South Asian Merchants.”
More prohibition
- Learning from alcohol prohibition
- If the people against ending drug prohibition had been around in the thirties, we would never have ended the prohibition of beer and cocktails, because of the dangers of pure alcohol and bathtub gin. One of the lessons of the alcohol prohibition era is that we don’t have to go from banning everything to allowing everything. There is a middle ground.
- Progressives ruin a different kind of race in New Jersey
- As a potential triple-crown winner prepares for the third race of the Triple Crown, it’s almost impossible to place a bet in Atlantic City, NJ.
- U.S. homicide rate compared to gun control measures
- Extrano’s Alley lists the U.S. homicide rate from 1885 to 1940, and somebody else puts it into a chart.
- The Great Illusion: An Informal History of Prohibition
- Herbert Asbury’s book has to rank as one of the greatest arguments ever written against the drug war; this book about alcohol prohibition chronicles and forecasts all of the problems with modern prohibition that we see today.
- Cannabis Britannica
- Subtitled “Empire, Trade, and Prohibition”, this is an in-depth history of how prohibition came about in Britain, and ends up describing how marijuana prohibition came to the forefront of international attempts to ban opium.
- 26 more pages with the topic prohibition, and other related pages
More racist laws
- Tuskegee deception aimed at whom?
- One major difference between the Tuskegee study and laws against affordable firearms is just how transparent the deceptions in favor of such laws are.
- Bad science dangerous to children
- It turns out that the term “meth babies” has as much basis in truth and science as the term “crack babies”: none whatsoever. Yet again, bad science is being used in defense of bad policy.
- Forfeiture, Racism, and Gun Control
- Racist laws in the post-war south also included forfeiture for pretty much the same reason forfeiture exists today.
- The self-defense Tuskegee
- Killing the poor with misplaced kindness. President Clinton cries “Never Again”, but that’s just newspeak for “ASAP”.