Two lessons for the price of one, for the Republican Party
One difference between conservatives and the left: when conservatives lose at the polls, they try to figure out what went wrong, whether they were wrong about their positions or whether they should try harder, or better, at convincing voters that their positions are right.
They look to see what they did wrong.
When the left loses at the polls—Brexit, or the early close race between Clinton and Trump—they blame the voter.1 The vision of the anointed can’t be wrong. They even float ideas for cutting voters out of the equation entirely. Appoint an expert to make the right decisions, or switch to a parliamentary system that puts politicians in charge of appointing the president.
But appointing a dictator, expert or not, never works out well for the anointed, whenever it’s been tried. They always turn out to be more of an expert at dictating, and worse of an expert than the millions of combined consumers who know what they want and how much they want to pay for it.
So, on the likely flawed assumption that conservatives and the Republican Party share members, here are two lessons the Republican Party should learn from this election year.
First, Republican voters need to stop nominating candidates who expect the press to treat them like Democrats. From McCain to Romney to Trump, they all seem to think that if they act like Democrats, the press will let them get away with it. That since the press isn’t searching out forty-year old documents in which Hillary Clinton said that a twelve-year-old rape victim was asking for it, the press is also going to give their own ancient history a pass.
Sure, a WikiLeaks or a Project Veritas that reveals criminal behavior of Democrats will be derided by the press because of its source. They’ll even tell their viewers not to go out to look for that dangerous information on their own. But the press would just as surely search through, and deputize their viewers to search through, the same material if it were about Republicans.
It doesn’t matter if you used to cozy up to the press to insult Republicans, as McCain did, or if you even used to be a Democrat, as Trump was. Once you’ve got that “R” behind your name, the press will not treat you like a Democrat.
Second, Republican leadership needs to stop trying to rig their nominating process for favored candidates. Favored candidates mean establishment candidates, and establishment candidacies are easily derailed by the press. This year’s primary was designed to catapult a well-known name with big money behind him to the nomination before oppo research could derail him. But that also meant that someone who got more press time would have a greater advantage than in a longer process. They meant the shorter nominating process to help Jeb Bush, but they got Donald Trump. Partly because the press kept pushing Donald Trump.
I’d say they should man up and switch to a superdelegate system like Democrats if they want to control who the nominee is, but see lesson one. What the Democrats got away with in this year’s primary to defeat Sanders behind the scenes, the press would not let Republicans get away with. Democrats can get away with rigging the system; Republicans can’t. But that doesn’t mean Republicans should continue a process that lets the press choose their candidate.
They need to lengthen the process, not shorten it. They need to turn the primary process into a crucible of fire. They need to encourage candidates to dig up dirt on each other. They might even offer the equivalent of bug bounty programs for third parties to dish the dirt on their candidates during the primary. In this election, Clinton told the press which candidate she wanted to face, and the press held back on that candidate. If a primary opponent can find it, the press will find it, after the nomination.
It may end up being an impossible task to keep the press from having some bad influence on the Republican primary process. But there’s no reason to make it easy on the press to do so.
Prior to the 2008 campaign, pundits in the press liked to complain that they liked substantive and serious candidates, and hated the gimmicks, the horse race, the flash. Then, they were outed as liars when they dumped on Fred Thompson for being substantive and serious. It isn’t just that shorter nominating processes require more money behind the candidates. The shorter the nominating process, the easier it is for the press to play up grandstanding, gimmicky candidates—like they did this year.
There’s a saying among those who watch the media that for the most part today’s press is “the propaganda arm of the Democratic Party”. It’s playing out very obviously during this election. Why should the Republican Party give the Democratic Party that much control over who their candidate is?
In response to Election 2016: Another fine mess you’ve gotten us into.
I still suspect that Britain will never, in fact, exit, despite the pro-exit vote. The anointed won’t let it happen. They’ll find some way to blame the voters, and then move on.
↑
- Hitler Learns Wikileaks Released Democrat Campaign Emails: Dal Rock
- Hitler learns that the collusion between the media and the Clinton campaign has gone public.
- Joe the Undecided Voter: Now Media “Vetting” Randomly Chosen Undecided Voter Who Dared to Ask Hillary About Obamacare: Ace at Ace of Spades HQ
- “I’m sure none of you are surprised by the media’s behavior here: You saw them ‘vet’ Joe the Plumber for asking Obama about wealth redistribution. The problem wasn’t the question Joe asked—it was Obama’s response… Well, Ken Bone hurt Hillary a little by asking a straight and fair question about Obamacare, so now he must be destroyed.”
- Sanctimony, Inc.: Victor Davis Hanson at National Review Online
- “Recently disgraced and resigned Democratic operatives, who were in the pay of the Democratic National Committee (and one of whom was a very frequent visitor to the Obama White House), boast on tape not only of disrupting Trump rallies by bought and staged violence but also of busing non-resident voters into Ohio to affect the vote count; they further brag that their dirty tricks are longstanding practice. When voting fraud is an act of pride rather than criminality, something has gone terribly wrong.”
- The Vision of the Anointed
- Would you believe that good intentions can defy the law of gravity? If not, you wouldn’t make a good politician in today’s America.
- What voters want
- An around-the-blog summary of reactions to Fred Thompson’s type-A president remarks. Are we designing the presidential elections to select kooks?
- Who creates more jobs, Democrats or Republicans?
- More jobs are created under gridlock than under unified governments. However, this only applies if Republicans hold at least one of the House or Senate.
More Election 2016
- The Parable of the Primary
- If Republicans are looking to be more Obama than Obama, they couldn’t have found a better cronyist than Donald Trump.
- The Hillary Clinton e-mail ‘scandal’ that isn’t
- There’s no there here, and it doesn’t affect her campaign. Nothing in the law says felons can’t be President.
- Why is the media saying Sanders lost the debate?
- Bernie Sanders spoke an important and inconvenient truth about socialism when he came to Hillary Clinton’s defense at the debates.
- Clinton vows UFO investigation
- Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton assures America she will investigate the UFOs of Area 51 and stand up to the vast ice cream conspiracy.
- Is Iowa the end of the game, or the beginning?
- It depends on whether your job is to win, or to guess the winner.
- 17 more pages with the topic Election 2016, and other related pages
More media bias
- The ruling class’s unexpectedly old clothes
- I recently ran across early use of “unexpectedly” for a conservative’s strong economy, referring to the early 1981 market recovery under President Reagan.
- COVID Lessons: Journalistic Delusions and the Madness of Politicians
- COVID-19 was real. The crisis surrounding it was entirely manufactured. Everything we did took a manageable disease and turned it into a killer. And the very worst was believing a media we knew was lying.
- How many fingers, America?
- The Orwellianization of the left continues.
- Has Trump forced the media into a Kobayashi Maru?
- The Kobayashi Maru is that the media wants to be able to continue lying and be believed. People don’t distrust them because of Trump. People distrust them because they keep lying. It is a self-caused problem.
- The institutional forgetfulness of the press
- We no longer have to rely on the press as our institutional memory. The Internet has made it harder for the left to pretend the past doesn’t exist, or to say one thing here and another there.
- 34 more pages with the topic media bias, and other related pages
More primaries
- The endless campaign
- Should we have endless political campaigns? That’s the Barack Obama plan, but is it right for American politics?
More Republicans
- The Life and Writings of Abraham Lincoln
- As the founding president of the Republican Party and the man who guided the United States through the incredible sacrifices of the Civil War and the abolition of slavery, Abraham Lincoln deserves more than adulation. He deserves to be read.
- The cyclic transmogrification of the Republican Party
- From Lincoln on, Democrats have accused Republicans of their own failings: hate speech, violence, madness. And the more the left recycles the same serpent’s lies they used against President Lincoln, the more the left turns Trump into the new Lincoln.
- Health insurance reform? What health insurance reform?
- The Truth About Republicans: they don’t want to repeal Obamacare.
- You want your party back; so do Trump supporters
- You want your party back? So do Trump supporters. Whether Republican or Democrat, their party is either leaving them or has left them. They want their jobs, their religion, and they especially want their voice back. Trump promises to be that voice.
- The Parable of the Primary
- If Republicans are looking to be more Obama than Obama, they couldn’t have found a better cronyist than Donald Trump.
- 10 more pages with the topic Republicans, and other related pages